Privacy

The Labor and delivery room in the main government hospital in downtown Port Au Prince is a single room with 25 or so metal beds placed 5 feet apart all facing center. There are 2" thick pads on the bed that are wiped off with a towel in between patients. Nurses, six of them, stand in the middle of the room chatting and wait until they determine a woman's cries to be indicative of impending birth, at which point they rush over with the sole OB physician, and deliver the baby. The baby is suctioned and toweled off by the nurses and handed back to the mother who will go home 6 hours later. 

Pediatricians are not present during the delivery, however if a baby comes out sick, or still, the nurse runs out of the room, out of the clinic, through the front gate, down to the end of the street and into the pediatric clinic where she must roam around looking for a physician who is able to leave his or her current patient. The summoned physician then briskly walks back along the nurse's path to the OB clinic to assess the situation. There is no vacuum suction, no oximeters, no oxygen, no x-ray, no ultrasound and no specialists.

Outside the delivery room is a long line of women sitting in chairs as though waiting to use the restroom, except they are waiting to get in to deliver. According to one nurse, many women deliver out in the waiting area.

Saving you further descriptive details of the birthing process in this common room, I want to say that privacy was not an element of the patient's experience. And more importantly, no one seemed to care. I thought about the ways in which we could improve the delivery process for the women here, would providing them more privacy serve any benefit? Of the many ideas I had to improve their care (i.e. more training for the MD's, availability of specialists, supplies, etc. etc.), privacy was not a consideration. Apparent, for example in the debate on the security of online PHRs, patient confidentiality and improving privacy is a major focus in the US healthcare system. Why? Do we have such an excess of resources to analyze, change, and implement that we go searching for elements of care to improve?

I returned to a country consumed with the debate on our healthcare system, and I found myself annoyed with its complexity. As I returned to my public health courses, and I learned more and more about our system, I knew that my opinions and involvement were altered because of my experience with a simpler, less convoluted system.

0
 
 

November 30, 2009
Note: This Perspectives Blog post is written by a Guest Blogger of DrGreene.com and is provided in order to offer a variety of thoughtful points of view. The opinions expressed on this Perspectives Blog post do not reflect the opinions of Dr. Greene or DrGreene.com. As such, Dr. Greene and DrGreene.com are not responsible for the accuracy of the information supplied. This post is used under Creative Commons License CC BY-ND 3.0.
 
  • Allowed HTML tags: <em> <strong> <cite> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.

Comments

Anonymous's picture

I find your words intriguing.

I find your words intriguing. Simple vs. complex. Isn't the answer always the simpler the better? Well, maybe not always, but in my mind, you have opened a new can of worms in my opinion. Perhaps we should stop focusing our time, effort, money (loads of money), and focus on whether or not the patient's bill reflects their bay window view properly, and focus more on the quality of the healthcare and how we can do a better job at keeping the population healthy. It pains me to know that women die waiting in the blistering sun because there was not a bed to deliver her baby. Are our questions of privacy really that large of an issue? We are all human. We run the same race. Maybe we should start looking outside the box; that red white and blue box that isn't always focusing on the big picture. People are dying. Do we REALLY care what the exact square footage is to the next patient's hospital bed? Thank you, Sally. I look forward to hearing more about you, your work, and your journey to becoming a physician. Til next time....
Anonymous's picture

Your insight into this

Your insight into this serious question is very intriguing, Sally. I find myself wanting to know more and see what you saw. When it comes to healthcare, should we really be spending energy and time and effort and money, loads of money, on comfort and pleasures? To deliver a baby, what does one really need? Can we do this better if we are not distracted by the complexities of who is paying the bill for the room with the bay window? People are dying, waiting in the sun to deliver their unborn babies and we are worrying about things that have never even entered their lives. I'm with you on this. Let's stop worrying about the small stuff and just get back to the basics. Maybe if we do this right, we will be able to spread efficient healthcare throughout the developing world.. one village at a time. I am interested to hear more about your work, travels, thoughts, and opinions. Thank you for sharing. Til next time.