Brown vs. White Rice: A Fork in the Road

blog_brownrice_whiterice.jpg

It’s time to change America’s first food. What if white rice helped trigger diabetes and brown rice helped to prevent it, regardless of lifestyle? That's just what a 2010 Harvard study suggests. Brown rice is a delicious whole food, packed with flavor and with protective nutrients. But all of the sugar-stabilizing fiber and all of the essential fatty acids are stripped out to make polished white rice, along with most of the magnesium, iron, B vitamins, and lignans, and half of the phosphorus and manganese. To make baby food rice cereal, the white rice is even further processed. And this depleted, out-of-balance, processed white flour becomes the eagerly-anticipated first bite of solids for most babies in the US.

How we feed babies in those early days matters for years to come. Most core food preferences are learned during critical early windows of opportunity (see Feeding Baby Green). In America we have raised a generation where most children learn to get zero servings of whole grains daily by the time they are 18 to 24 months old.

One in three babies born today is expected to develop diabetes in their lifetime, unless something dramatic changes. If we just made the simple switch from white rice to brown rice for babies we might cultivate a taste for whole grains and prevent millions and millions of people from developing diabetes.

For that very first bite of solids, though, I prefer choosing something that doesn’t come in a box or jar. Let your baby see a real whole food in its natural state, something she’s seen you eat before, such as a banana or an avocado. Let her handle the whole food. Let her smell it. Let her see you eat some, and then let her see you mash up a bit, perhaps with some breast milk. If you are nursing, she will already have experienced the flavor in your breast milk before.

Her strong desire to imitate you and to learn from you, coupled with this powerful combination of seeing, tasting, smelling, and touch creates a profound learning experience that is deeply satisfying and fun. Let a whole food mark this momentous occasion – or a whole grain cereal. But not processed white flour rice cereal.

Researchers at the Harvard School of Public Health analyzed rice eating and diabetes in about 200,000 people. Those who ate white rice 5 or more times a week had a 17% increased risk of type 2 diabetes compared with those who ate it less than once a month. Separately, those who ate 2 or more servings of brown rice a week had an 11 % decrease of type 2 diabetes. But the biggest difference came in those who chose brown rice or another whole grain instead of white rice – with up to a 36% reduced risk.

If we have a future population of 300 million in the US, with 100 million expected to develop diabetes, a 36% reduced risk represents a huge savings of life, limb, eyesight, money and health.

Shortly after babies begin to walk, neophobia begins to set in, the fear of new flavors, textures, or sources of food. Let’s teach a love for whole grains (and other whole foods) while they are still so eager to learn!

Sun Q, Spiegelman D, van Dam RM, Holmes MD, Malik VS, Willett WC, and Hu FB. “White Rice, Brown Rice, and Risk of Type 2 Diabetes in US Men and Women. Archives of Internal Medicine. June 2010; 170(11):961-969.

4.666665
 
 
 
  • Allowed HTML tags: <em> <strong> <cite> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.

Comments

Anonymous's picture

My girls love brown rice

My two girls eat whole cereals, fruits, vegetables, they have a educate taste , its easy, only give our babys a chance to taste simple, healthy wholefood. I coock my brown cereal in rice macker(licke japan restaurant use for sushi rice) its so easy and ist warm wen i wonted, even barley, yamani rice and quinoa. Millet its grate for babys. I have my blog is about healthy recipies for kidts, I´m Chef and worck with nutritionist and a pediatrician , given worck shop for parents , in Argentina! Wow I sou happy to found profesional with my same passion and ideas about children healths.
Anonymous's picture

Whole grain cereal alternative?

I am starting my infant on solids, and was never keen on the rice cereal. The only other cereal option I see is oat. Would this be sufficient? Also, I have read on Dr. Mercola's site that a babies first solid should be egg yolk. What are your thought's on this?

Reply

Qucik Guide to Starting Solids

Have you seen Dr. Greene's Quick Guide to Starting Solids? He answers your questions and more in very concise and easy to follow one-page guide.
Anonymous's picture

Im confused. I have read and

Im confused. I have read and been told by WIC that rice is better for a babies stomach because it is easy to digest. Cooked brown rice is always so tough and chewy. Isnt it harder for baby's immature digestive track to break down mushed up brown rice? Should I boil it to mush first, or would that cook out all the vitamins?
Anonymous's picture

More to Study

I do believe the focus is in the wrong area. More research points at formula feeding as the real problem. Breastfeeding is the answer, I say white rice is the least of our worries.

Reply

Breast is best!

We are in complete agreement that human milk is better for babies than anything else they could drink before they start solid foods. Increasing the number of kids who breastfeed and how long they breastfeed is an important goal in the US and around the world. I continue to work towards that goal. But when kids do start solids, what they eat matters. There is no good scientific or practical reason to give babies the white flour that we call rice cereal. Because there are simple, easily available alternatives (like fruits, veggies, whole grains), why don't we just end this practice within a year and be done with it? Rice cereal isn't just the first few bites of food. This "bad" carb is the #1 source of all food carbs in the first year (I'm not talking about liquid carbs here, but it still outpaces breastmilk or juice in the second half of the year). And, more than that, this empty white flour is the #1 source of all food calories for the typical American child from the first breath to the first step. With what we now know scientifically about how food preferences develop (See the ~20 pages of references in Feeding Baby Green), it's no wonder that the white flour cereal gives way to the typical kids meals of white buns, macaroni, grilled cheese, and even white-breaded chicken nuggets. Or that the #1 source of calories for the average school-aged child on a typical in the US is white-flour-based sweets. I do hope we can end white rice cereal this year, but my bigger goal is to ignite a conversation about food habits for babies and toddlers (where breastfeeding should be a centerpiece) - and ultimately to cultivate Nutritional Intelligence in kids - the age-appropriate ability to recognize and enjoy healthy amounts of healthy food.
Anonymous's picture

Plaudits re your conclusions on brown rice as first food

5
We are modernly afflicted by bad advice in regard to nutrition. Your views on white rice versus brown rice as a first food represent welcome relief. Thank you. Children everywhere would thank you if they but knew of the opportunity. Ray Claude
Anonymous's picture

My baby has never liked the

5
My baby has never liked the taste of rice cereal even if I mix bmilk in it. We are very fortunate to have read this article from Dr. Greene. Now we know not to make our baby get used to the taste of rice cereal.

Such an important topic...

And it's nice to hear people buzzing about it. I've already received emails about this article on the site and what people fed their children first. Katie Newell (a health food nut whose recipes are going up on the site soon. Can't wait for them!) fed her kids avocados -- yum! Makes me wonder what food other people fed their kids first? Share below what you fed your little ones! It is such a significant life step for babies, I think it's great to recognize what weight it has for them and their healthy future.

Easy Brown Rice

5
Some people don't make brown rice because it takes longer to cook. Here are my tips for making brown rice along with some great ways to add veggie into your diet -- http://www.drgreene.com/recipe/green-rice
Anonymous's picture

Glucose Index

I was told that brown rice has a higher glucose index than white rice? Is that true?
Anonymous's picture

Down with Rice Cereal as a Baby's First Taste of "Food"!

Happy to see you addressing this :) I was very pleased to see this comment from Nov. 2009 Pediatric News by Frank Greer (AAP Committee on Nutrition) "Rice cereal has traditionally been the first complementary food given to American infants, but Complementary foods introduced to infants should be based on their nutrient requirements and the nutrient density of foods, not on traditional practices that have no scientific basis,” Dr. Greer said in an interview. Slowly the word is trickling out that boxed rice cereal isn't the be-all end-all for baby's first food! Hooray! Maggie wholesomebabyfood.com